|
Author
|
Topic: no starch diet
|
Waks Registered Visitor Posts: 6 Registered: Nov 2002
|
posted December 05, 2002 11:03 AM
AS is one condition I have learn't can change the way it wants you to behave. Last year, exercising for me was the key thing. This year, with the increased dosage in my cocktail, alot of rest and sleep was the in thing for me. I mean I could feel alot of pain, take a nap and I would be fine. Too bad that's changed. I can hardly sleep for a straight 3 hrs now. I have to change my positions every so often. I could sleep ony back all night and do well(when napping was the in thing) Now I can hardly sleep on back for long. On either side, too painful too. On my stomach, for 2 hrs max then of course I will wake up with additional neck pain. I have to set the alarm an hour before I wake now, so that I can take some pain med(the powerful kind). With that, I will at least be able to shower faster and get on my day. Without pain med it takes me 3-4 hrs. Through it all though exercise has helped a whole lot, I would vote for it. AS tends to be very personal. Wish you all luck.
IP: Logged |
AS-SUCKS unregistered
|
posted November 27, 2002 09:38 AM
I have exercised, walked, etc....I don't think it helps the pain and in fact, can make it way worse. Also, I seem to have a limited amount of energy and need to use it wisely. Walking and swimming are the best. But, if I walk too much, the bursitis in my legs (outer thighs) gets so bad I cannot sleep. Guess it is due to poor hip flexibility. I also pay if I lie around too much. 6-7 hrs a night in bed is more than enough. Any more and I get so miserably stiff. Hard to find a balance. This AS stuff is no fun. Anyone that tries to paint some positive slant to this needs to be lynched.
IP: Logged |
raddeester Registered Visitor Posts: 8 Registered: Nov 2002
|
posted November 27, 2002 06:22 AM
I use a 75 cm. exercise ball. get the biggest one...do your crunches on it (i do 300 a day) i also lay on it on my back and do a thorasic spread eagle arms out. hold this position as long as u can!!! SEVERAL TIMES A DAY!!! you can do this in your living rooom watching your fav show, so its not boring!!! PLUS!!!!!!!! It puts your spine in the correct ALIGNMENT!!!! rather than laying on a hard FLAT floor..thats theworst thing u can do for a fusing spine!!! get the ball!!! there avail at DICKS, GAYALNS, AND prob SEARS..MAKE SURE U GET THE BIGGEST ONE!!! Its 75 cm. (centimeters) the crunches strenghthen your lower back muscles and tighten everything up!!! really helped my back pain..but the stretching on the back on the ball really is the key to slow the fusion...TRY IT there approx 24-32 $ CHEAP!!!!
IP: Logged |
twisks Registered Visitor Posts: 4 Registered: Nov 2002
|
posted November 27, 2002 02:48 AM
The London AS Diet and the NSD aren't just low carb - they are low STARCH (or NO starch)There can be plently of pitfalls along the way to the unitiated, which is why the support and knowledge that have been there is important. If you're not responding to it, there is generally a good reason why. Exercise is important too, actually it is non-negotiable, some form of exercise should be done daily with AS. My personal favourite is Pilates, and the diet has enabled me to do the full programme, as before I was frequently in too much pain to go beyond the warm-up. Best wishes, Jan
IP: Logged |
kdxyardsale Registered Visitor Posts: 6 Registered: Nov 2002
|
posted November 26, 2002 05:55 PM
Tried low carb diet after moderate suffering of AS for 15 yrs, in diet 6 mos= worst pain and stiffnes ever with this disease. Back to milk, meat, pasta, greens, tomaters, etc.. My exercise program makes mine tons better, 3x week on the bowflex and a couple of days hiking or biking about an hour. When I get sorer (is that a word?) it is after skipping a few days exercise. When I start exercising again, the pain gets worse a day or two and then after sticking with it goes mostly away. Add that to your own research and do what works for you best, It seems AS has to be treated different by each individual to work best for them, so try things until something works for you. Best of luck.
IP: Logged |
twisks Registered Visitor Posts: 4 Registered: Nov 2002
|
posted November 26, 2002 08:16 AM
I can see how people may well be sceptical of this diet...I was too. But knowing there'd be no way I could get off my meds to allow for a pregnancy, and then having a run of BAD side-effects from Vioxx, I decided to take a leap of faith and give it a go.Know what? Turned out to be the best thing I ever did. My pain is minimal, I can sleep, I have energy. I feel almost as good as I did before my AS started. This kooky sounding diet has given me my life back. I would strongly advocate anyone trying it. You too could feel this good!!! BTW, I was doing all the researchy-stuff, but Ebringer had huge blocks in his way preventing full research of his work. That's why a lot of Rheumy's don't advocate it. I'm not worried about the lack of published evidence, he did a lot of work over some years, and a lot of his patients continue to reap the benefits. All that really matters is that personal research has shown it WORKS, better than any med could. What more could I possibly want? Take a look at www.kickas.org folks, there's info on the front page, and a designated NSD forum inside. Take care, Jan
IP: Logged |
michel unregistered
|
posted July 15, 2002 12:26 PM
You guys are right, my choice of sports is probably not the best. I don’t do them that often anymore. One exercise that works really well for me is climbing stairs. Somedays i go to a location where there are about 210 stairs in a row and run up and down as much as i can. I must say that for me, this is the only exercise that i can do painlessly and get an incredible cardio workout. I would recommend it for everyone whos knees are in good shape(as long as you maintain good posture and some good sports shoes). Swimming is another story! When i am in water i hyperventilate and have difficulty breathing. This is mainly due to a childhood incidence where i nearly drowned. Ya, i know i should be seeing a psych for that!!! Soon, i hope! michel
IP: Logged |
Spenser23 Registered Visitor Posts: 157 Registered: Nov 2001
|
posted July 15, 2002 11:49 AM
I understand your point, and agree with you, Michel.Keeping active is so important, but it is no guarantee that your pain will be eliminated totally. On a side note, I would be a bit nervous playing basketball, (the way they play here in NYC, it is definitely a full contact sport), and rollerblading, where the dangers of a fall would be multiplied by my having AS, but to each his own, I guess. Be careful. As someone else in another thread mentioned, have you considered swimming or some other non-contact sports? Take Care.
Spenser23@aol.com
IP: Logged |
spanky28 unregistered
|
posted July 15, 2002 11:41 AM
I have to agree with Michel, I have done various exercising over the years and usually wind up in more pain than I had before. I really think its different for everyone. However, I do think it does help physically....but yes, LOTS o' pain!!
IP: Logged |
michel unregistered
|
posted July 15, 2002 07:30 AM
hi Spencer, I think we should all be active and do as much exercise as possible. I just don’t think it is fair for someone(like Anky What) to preach to others that they will magically rid themselves of their pain if they suddenly start doing exercise. It may work for some but is false for someone like myself.My pain has worsened every year. When i was younger and did sports every day i used to get regular back and sacrum/pelvis injuries(obviously i was unaware of what i had). Now i am at a point where after a sport (such as badminton, basketball or rollerblading) i come home in so much pain that i must immediately take strong pain killers and basically i lose sleep for the entire night. Also in general, my pain is at its worst at about 4 am. This is a type of pain that comes with having been immobile for several hours. This pain has never improved with exercise and in fact has worsened throughout the years. I will continue to do sports and stretching for many years to come but more in the hope to slow and prevent complete fusion of the spine. take care michel
IP: Logged |
Spenser23 Registered Visitor Posts: 157 Registered: Nov 2001
|
posted July 14, 2002 08:59 PM
Sorry to hear you are in pain, Michel. Of course, you never know how much greater the pain might be if you did NOT exercise. It's tough to contemplate, but maybe this IS a lesser degree of pain, thanks to exercise. Just a thought.
Spenser23@aol.com
IP: Logged |
michel unregistered
|
posted July 14, 2002 06:55 PM
Sorry Anky What, i am living proof that excercise does not reduce pain(in all cases of AS sufferers). In my case it has helped to slow down the fusing(i believe and i hope) but MY GOD not the pain!!!!!michel
IP: Logged |
mutt Registered Visitor Posts: 44 Registered: Jan 2002
|
posted July 14, 2002 08:32 AM
Clearly exercise can benefit more than just your AS.
IP: Logged |
Anky What unregistered
|
posted July 14, 2002 07:26 AM
One of the few times I agree with Mutt. The NSD has to be hype. Since starting my exercise program I feel great and eat all kinds of starchy food and feel great. It's not what you eat it's all about a good exercise program. Start working those muscles and free yourself from pain and eat what you like and start living again.
IP: Logged |
mutt Registered Visitor Posts: 44 Registered: Jan 2002
|
posted July 14, 2002 07:16 AM
Going back to the no-starch diet, there's no scientific proof that it helps with AS.The diet is advocated by a rheumatologist in England (Dr. Ebringer, since retired) based on some background science, and on the diets observed effect on patients from his practice. The background science is that it is believed that AS is triggered by a bacteria which has cell surface molecules that closely resemble other moleules in our bodies. These cell surface molecules get attacked by our immune system which then remembers their shape and so starts to attack similarly shaped molecules in our bodies, thereby causing AS. Those ideas are not so controversial, however, Ebringer extended them by noting that a good candidate bacteria was Klebsiella, and that Klebsiella occurs mostly in the gut. The gut is also close to the lower back and SI joints, and so a continual immune reaction in the gut might somehow be transfered to those areas. This hypothesis motivates the diet since apparently Klebsiella feeds on starch and so if starch levels are reduced in the diet then the Klebsiella levels will also be, leading ultimately to reduced AS activity. Dr. Ebringer published these ideas in a few areas, but nothing peer-reviewed (which is how an idea gets accepted). Most rheumatologists do not believe in the diet, and I think the reason is that if the AS were due to a bacterial infection, then AS would respond to antibiotics. Antibiotics could basically remove all of the bacteria from the system. Apparently there is no AS response antibiotics. So, although bacteria or viruses may trigger AS (and probably do), there is no evidence that after the initial event they play a role. Once the immune system has been triggered, the body takes it from there. Personally, I'd like to see some more research done on the diet, if only in that the idea has taken hold among enough AS-sufferers. If a little money was spent to get scientifically defendable results and so settle the issue I think that that would be a good thing. If someone wants to believe in something to help them deal with AS, and if by believing in that thing they get get relief then of course that's also a good thing. However, there are of course alot of things that we can believe in, and the problem with the diet is that, at the moment, it is presented as science when it's not. Someone might think that based on the science, the approach is as worth trying as a proven method (ex: anti-tnf drug), and so try the diet instead of proven treatment. Anyway, that's my .02. Also, as far as simple things to believe in for AS, try exercise. There *is* support for that with AS. It may even have some small effect on TNF-alpha levels, there are some recent papers (for other diseases) on some kind of a connection there.
IP: Logged |
Anky What unregistered
|
posted July 13, 2002 07:27 AM
People should do whatever makes them feel better. I eat anything I want and feel great most of the time. What does it for me is swimming in a heated pool and working out at the gym using exercise equipment. I get a natural high after a good workout and am almost pain free and have stoped using all medications. Bring on the pizza and potatoes, whatever, a good exercise program kicks butt.
IP: Logged |
Kathy Registered Visitor Posts: 66 Registered: Jun 2002
|
posted July 09, 2002 08:08 PM
I have no personal experience with a no starch diet being of benefit, but I do have personal experience with a no gluten & no dairy diet. I have also read a number of old messages on this board that seem to indicate that gluten intolerance is common in a great many AS patients (gluten and gliaden are contained in wheat and some other grains like rye, spelt, barley and oats. When they eat these gluten containing foods they will have an immune response. Any immune response is likely to aggravate your AS symptoms, which is also an auto immune disease. Your intestines are lined with villi (like little spikes standing straight up) The ends of the villi produce an enzyme called lactase, which digests the lactose in milk. It is common for gluten sensitive persons to also suffer from lactose intollerance...because when gluten containing food is ingested, the villi lay flat against the walls of the intestine, and they stop producing lactase--meaning you no longer can tolerate the lactose in milk. So, by eliminating the gluten in your diet, the villi will stand up straight again and start producing lactase again. It makes sense that if you are not bombarding your system with stuff if doesn't like, your whole immune system will remain calmer. When I'm being "bad" and eat gluten containing foods several days in a row, I start aching all over, in addition to having the accompanying IB symptoms. Aloha, Kathy
IP: Logged |
wonderin' unregistered
|
posted July 09, 2002 05:06 PM
I was doing some reading on another AS forum. I came across people who claim that giving up starch in their diets or eating a low starch diet has eased the pain of their AS. In some cases it is gone altogether. Is there any scientific proof about this strain of bacteria that they seem to claim is somewhere at the root of AS? Is the answer to AS as simple as a dietary change? It seems rather strange to me, but these people sound sincere in what they are saying.
IP: Logged | |